NY Times…Gutter Journalism?

 Most people are aware that the New York Times published a story about republican presidential hopeful John McCain’s alleged “improper relationship” with lobbyist Vicki Iseman, during his 1999 run for the White House. Most people are also aware that this “relationship” has been denied by both parties. This post isn’t about attacking McCain or the other presidential hopefuls; this is about journalism and honesty.

The New York Times was in bad taste to publish a story based on decade-old evidence from unidentified McCain aides instead of named sources. The first thing they teach in “journalism 101”, make sure you’re sources are valid, and your story can be corroborated. The New York Times neglected to do that.

                             

Sure enough “the liberal media” was immediately under attack from the more conservative publications and chat show personalities waiting in the wings to pounce. Rush Limbaugh commented that the New York Times article was evidence of a complete media conspiracy against the Republican Party.

                      

 Again, I believe the New York Times made a mistake by printing this story, but a total media conspiracy? Please.

                 

This immediate right wing backlash intrigued me, because I’m well aware that conservative news outlets are quick to blame the “liberal media”. In an interview with former Speaker of the House, Newt Gingrich, Bill O’reilly posed this question: Shouldn’t McCain now attack the New York Times and make them the villain?

                       

 “You know speaker, I’m so sick of the unfair, liberal media. These people aren’t being honest, they’re not reporting the news,” O’reilly said. “I’m so sick of their smears and innuendo”.

                    

 I wonder if that’s what the New York Times said about O’reilly when he told a 9/11 victim’s son to “shut up”, and that his father would be ashamed of him if he were alive?